The purpose of the National Minimum Wage (NMW) is to ensure that workers receive decent pay packets, into their own hands and free from deductions. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) underlined

that point in ruling that a football club failed to pay the NMW because it deducted cash from employees’ wages to pay for season tickets.

Football crowdThe club enabled members of its clerical and hospitality staff to obtain season tickets for members of their families. The cost of those tickets was deducted from their pay packets by instalments. HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) took the view that those deductions reduced the relevant workers’ remuneration to below the NMW and issued the club with underpayment notices pursuant to Section 19 of the National Minimum Wage Act 1998.

In challenging the notices, the club argued that the arrangement with its employees was entirely voluntary. There was no suggestion that it amounted to an attempt to obtain a tax advantage or to avoid paying the NMW. The club’s appeal to an Employment Tribunal (ET) was allowed and the notices quashed.

In upholding HMRC’s challenge to that outcome, the EAT noted that, with very limited exceptions, employees are required to pay money for workers’ services into their own hands. A deduction from wages occurs whenever an employer withholds money from a worker’s pay packet at source, regardless of the underlying purpose of doing so.

Although there was no suggestion that club employees had been pressured to enter into the arrangement, a restrictive interpretation of the relevant rules was necessary to ensure that workers who purchase goods or services from their employers do so as a matter of free choice. The arrangement, whilst benefiting the club’s employees, was also for the club’s own use and benefit in that it ultimately received payment in full for the season tickets. The underpayment notices were reinstated.

Submit to DeliciousSubmit to DiggSubmit to FacebookSubmit to Google PlusSubmit to StumbleuponSubmit to TechnoratiSubmit to TwitterSubmit to LinkedIn

Latest News

Contact Us

DMD Solicitors

3 Exeter House
Beaufort Court
Sir Thomas Longley Road
Rochester
Kent
ME2 4FE
Tel: 44 (0) 1634 735530
Fax: 44 (0) 1634 735532
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

 

If you have a legal question please send an e-mail to us for an initial response.

 

Contact Us

 

 

Our Clients Feedback

I have recommended DMD to both friends and relatives as the fees were competitive and the time charged was reasonable and in particular for Lindseys direct approach to issue. Ms M


Read More...

The whole service given was with understanding and helpfulness by all the staff and nothing was too much trouble in helping us.


Read More...

What could we do to improve the service you received from us? Could not - it was great Mr H


Read More...

Both my son and I have been very happy with the attention received and would not hesitate to recommend you to friends. BH


Read More...

The service was very good and fast and the staff very kind. It was value for money and I am very happy with the service because my son had a case with someone else and it took longer than me, so thank you very much. Mr and Mrs K


Read More...

Our case was dealt with in an efficient and pleasant manner. It needed clear legal advice to resolve so it was worth the cost. We were pleased with the service especially with the time that was taken to ensure we understood all of the aspects of the Power of Attorney...


Read More...

What could we do to improve the service you received form us? Nothing we were very pleased with the service. MD


Read More...

Service was excellent Mrs JH


Read More...

I was given an excellent service, giving good clear advice and was able to satisfy my request with a quick turnaround. I will certainly be recommending you to my friends and colleagues. Ms JA


Read More...

Thank you for all your help and for making things easier for me at a difficult time, and a thank you to all your friendly, cheerful staff.


Read More...

Communication and assistance have always been great from DMD and will recommend DMD to anyone I know. I understood the procedures all the way through the service. Everything on the conveyance was completed in a timely manner and to a high standard. I could never fault or ask for more...


Read More...

I came to you with a sensitive problem and the matter was treated with upmost sensitivity. You could not improve your services as from receptionist to solicitor the service was 100 percent. T A FIlippi


Read More...

Gave us great advice at every stage. Colin Atkins


Read More...

I felt comfortable enough to ask any questions. Informative service, would return for any other legal advice. S Mead


Read More...

Friendly and helpful staff in my time of stress made everything easy for me.


Read More...

I would recommend the practice to a colleague, friend or family member as everything happened as promised from the start.


Read More...

Very informative and helpful in dealing with our request.


Read More...

Memberships

DMD Solicitors is the trading name of Dakers Marriott Dugdale Ltd

(Co. No. 08797418) and is authorised and regulated by the SRA (No. 611613)

Copyright © 2011-2014. All Rights Reserved.

Accessibility, Legal Notices, Cookies, Privacy, Sitemap